The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority filed a proposal with the Securities and Exchange Commission this week to give Wall Street firms a majority on its governing board for the first time in three decades. The move would reverse a 1996 mandate that required FINRA's predecessor to maintain a public-member majority to prevent conflicts of interest and address enforcement problems.
The proposal calls for a minimum of seven industry governors and at least five from the public. It would also shrink the board to a maximum of 20 members from 25. FINRA said in the filing the factors in play 30 years ago are significantly different from the environment the regulator faces today.
FINRA's board oversees the self-regulatory organization, which can bar or suspend bad actors and levy financial penalties. The regulator tracks stock and option trades, and its surveillance teams send tips and referrals to the SEC about potential insider trading and stock-manipulation schemes.
The proposed structure would bring FINRA in line with other market self-regulators, like the National Futures Association, which helps oversee the derivatives industry. The changes preserve important safeguards for FINRA's regulatory mission and consensus-driven approach to governance, the regulator said in a statement.
Former SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce argued in a 2015 academic paper that FINRA's current structure means it is not accountable to industry or the public. An organization run by a board that is dominated by people who are not in the industry is not an SRO, it is a regulator with industry representation, Peirce wrote.
The proposal is likely to raise questions about FINRA's independence. A regulator that's not just ideologically captured but actually structurally captured by the entities it regulates, you really have to question not just willingness but also its ability to do its job, said Tyler Gellasch, chief executive officer of the Healthy Markets Association.
The SEC will take public comment on the proposal for 21 days.
