Commercial Property Premiums Fall 6.2% in Third Quarter as Soft Market Persists

Large accounts saw the steepest declines for a full year, while commercial auto rose for the 61st consecutive quarter.

By the Family Office Real Estate Daily Desk·Thursday, November 19, 2026·1 min read
Editorial summary of reporting byInsurance JournalOur editorial standards →
The answer · checked against Insurance Journal

How much did commercial property insurance premiums change in Q3 2026 and which lines saw the biggest moves?

The Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers (CIAB) Q3 2026 market survey found average commercial insurance premiums decreased 1.3% across all account sizes, a slight moderation from a 2% decrease in Q2. Commercial property led all lines with a 6.2% decline, while commercial auto rose 6.7% for the 61st consecutive quarter of increases. Large accounts posted the steepest declines for a full year.

Key facts
  • The Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers (CIAB) Q3 2026 survey found average commercial insurance premiums decreased 1.3% across all account sizes.
  • Commercial property recorded the largest premium decrease of all lines at 6.2% in Q3 2026, approximately the same as Q2, according to CIAB.
  • Directors and officers (D&O) premiums decreased 4.1% in Q3 2026, widening from a 2.1% decrease the prior quarter, according to CIAB.
  • Workers compensation premiums decreased 3.6% in Q3 2026, according to the CIAB survey.
  • Large account premiums fell 3.1% in Q3 2026, marking a full year in which large accounts showed the greatest decrease of all account sizes, according to CIAB.
  • Commercial auto premiums increased 6.7% in Q3 2026, the 61st consecutive quarter of increases, according to CIAB.
Commercial Property Premiums Fall 6.2% in Third Quarter as Soft Market Persists
Image: editorial illustration · Story sourced from Insurance Journal

Commercial insurance premiums fell an average of 1.3% in the third quarter of 2026, driven by a 6.2% decline in commercial property rates, according to the Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers. The drop represents a slight moderation from the second quarter, when premiums decreased 2% across all account sizes.

The survey found increased competition among carriers for business and greater willingness to compromise on pricing to secure accounts. Nine lines of business recorded premium decreases in the quarter: business interruption, construction, commercial property, cyber, directors and officers, employment practices, surety bonds, terrorism, and workers compensation.

Directors and officers insurance premiums fell 4.1%, an acceleration from the 2.1% decrease in the prior quarter. Workers compensation premiums dropped 3.6%. Commercial property recorded about the same decline as it had in the second quarter.

Large account premiums fell 3.1%, marking a full year in which large accounts showed the greatest decrease of all account sizes, CIAB said. The softening came as carriers competed more intensely for business in a market that has shown no meaningful change in pricing conditions.

Commercial auto insurance bucked the trend, with premiums rising 6.7% in the third quarter. The increase marked the 61st consecutive quarter of premium growth for the line. Commercial auto premiums had risen 4.5% in the second quarter.

Outside of commercial auto, all major lines of commercial business — auto, property, workers compensation, general liability, and umbrella — showed increases of 3.1% or less. The Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers described the market conditions as stubbornly soft with no meaningful change from the prior quarter.

The Deployment Angle

Family Office Real Estate Daily Desk · our analysis, not the source's

Family offices holding stabilized real estate should use this pricing environment to renegotiate property insurance ahead of annual renewals, particularly for large accounts where the decline exceeds the market average by more than two percentage points. Lock in multi-year agreements now while carriers are compromising on price to win business.

The 6.2% property premium decline warrants a margin-of-safety review. If carriers are cutting rates this aggressively while catastrophe losses remain elevated, underwriting discipline is eroding. Verify that your insurer maintains an A.M. Best rating of A- or higher and that your broker is spreading limits across multiple carriers rather than concentrating exposure with one aggressive underwriter.

For families deploying capital into direct real estate acquisitions, model insurance expense at current soft-market rates but stress-test pro formas at a 10% annual increase beginning in 2028. Soft markets do not persist. The 61-quarter run in commercial auto premiums demonstrates how quickly a line can decouple when loss experience deteriorates. Build that reversion into your underwriting and avoid deals that cannot withstand a return to 2021-2022 property premium levels.

Questions this story answers

01How much did commercial property insurance premiums change in Q3 2026?

According to the Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers (CIAB) Q3 2026 market survey, commercial property recorded the largest premium decrease of all lines at 6.2%, approximately the same as Q2 2026. CIAB attributed the soft conditions to increased competition among carriers and increased willingness to compromise on pricing.

02Are commercial insurance premiums still falling across all lines in 2026?

CIAB's Q3 2026 survey found premiums decreased in nine lines of business, including commercial property, D&O, workers compensation, cyber, and others. However, commercial auto was the exception, rising 6.7% in Q3 2026 for its 61st consecutive quarter of increases. The overall average decrease across all accounts was 1.3%.

03Which commercial insurance lines saw the biggest premium decreases in Q3 2026?

According to CIAB's Q3 2026 survey, commercial property led all lines with a 6.2% decrease, followed by directors and officers at down 4.1%, and workers compensation at down 3.6%. CIAB reported that nine lines in total recorded premium decreases in Q3 2026.

05Is commercial auto insurance still seeing premium increases in 2026?

Yes. According to CIAB's Q3 2026 market survey, commercial auto premiums increased 6.7% in Q3 2026, marking the 61st consecutive quarter of increases for that line. This compares to a 4.5% increase in Q2 2026, indicating the rate of increase accelerated quarter over quarter.

Original reporting
Insurance Journal
Read the original at Insurance Journal →
insurancecommercial-propertyrisk-managementunderwriting
Peer Network · By Invitation

The Thesis Exchange

Share an investment thesis in confidence. We pair you anonymously with up to two other family offices running adjacent strategies. Reviewed by Gallium's editorial team. No vendor pitch.